I was on this very board, asking this very question about a year ago. First of all, these people are great, secondly, they told me to go with what I felt. I went Digital, started with a Kontrol S2 and F1 combo along with a $200 laptop off eBay, a year later I have a regular paying club night, and have had a few shows regionally. I have not questioned my decision. I was mostly worried about appearances (i.e. will people see me as less professional), but those worries went away as I gained experience with the gear and improved through practice.