I think the reloop will kill both of those options, its solid has lots of functions, but the only thing bad about the unit is the eq knobs are push to kill, that means they wobble a bit, they are fantastic quality chassis mounted knobs but they feel pretty bad on the jockey 2, I recommend getting your hands on one before making the purchase. It will also depend on the software you prefer, I know traktor has issues supporting jog wheels, if traktor is your choice get a native traktor controller.