You are right they both are great controllers. I’m not sure about beginner controllers, they are more proffesional as to what controllers can go, if you’re starting I would recommend a Numark, Vestax or Reloop in my opinion, depending on the model of course. Oh and also, it’s not of course everyone but at least me when it comes to used gear, I dont like to buy it, maybe its almost new or anything, I still don’t trust it, and it cost maybe a little less than a brand new so my advice is save a little more money and buy a new controller, hope this helps. Good luck -Spin