Home 2023 Forums The DJ Booth Ever purposely post a mix with a few minor mistakes?

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1012641
    Dirty Hippie
    Member

    I posted a mix on soundcloud recently with similar type errors. I went ahead commented on my mistakes in advance. It kept the flaming down and let people know I heard it, but still felt it was worth sharing.

    #1012643
    D-Jam
    Participant

    I’ve posted mixes with a timing error or some “drift off” in a blend.

    It’s what makes people know you’re human.

    #1012657
    B.B. Koning
    Participant

    Dirty Hippie, post: 29071, member: 4027 wrote: I posted a mix on soundcloud recently with similar type errors. I went ahead commented on my mistakes in advance. It kept the flaming down and let people know I heard it, but still felt it was worth sharing.

    Thanks. I was sort of bandying about the idea of doing what you suggest here when posting it.

    The Soundcloud community aren’t quite You Tube caliber of insulting, but you do tend to get honest assessments. Many times the line between honesty and downright insulting gets crossed more quickly than you’d like.

    At the end of the day, it’s the essence and the substance that counts, I think.

    #1012658
    B.B. Koning
    Participant

    D-Jam, post: 29073, member: 3 wrote: I’ve posted mixes with a timing error or some “drift off” in a blend.

    It’s what makes people know you’re human.

    I keep up with your posts, so I know you’ve been in the game for quite some time. It is very re-assuring to know that you’re of that mindset. Thanks for the encouragement/affirmation.

    #1012668
    softcore
    Member

    I agree with D-Jam! Few days ago a producer-DJ told me that he records his sets (the ones he uploads to places like Soundcloud etc. etc.) by layering the tracks in Ableton Live and doing automation edits to make the mix. Surely they will sound perfect in timing, but I was disgusted at the idea that no actual performance-DJing is involved in this process.

    One or two erros in the mix, reminds the listener that what he listens to is an actual mix and not some result after hour of editing with a freaking automation draw pencil in your software.

    #1012697
    Erik Toth
    Participant

    I always play my mixes live. I tried once to make the same thing in ableton but honestly it took longer time than to do it in traktor and at the end it didnt feel right so I skipped it.
    It was my first longer (1 hour) set ever so I told myself it’s more safe to that way than the live way.
    Honestly I rather re-start a recording if I fail big time than make the whole set in ableton.
    Nowadays if/when I make a bigger mistake during recording I pause for a sec and do it again and later I can delete the unwanted places in ableton.
    If it’s minor things like sudden volume thing or something like that, I let them go…after all, it’s live.

    #1012719
    Terry_42
    Keymaster

    I actually only put things that are not perfect on soundcloud and youtube… most of it to demo what went wrong and some of it even not played by me, but one of my students and some of it just experiments.

    #1012721
    NewportDJ Drew
    Participant

    One shot one take keeps it real.

    #1012731
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Yes, anyone with a brain could make perfect mixes using Ableton Live , however such mixes, unless they are spiced with tons of creativity, sound very sterile. Better do a more human mix with small imperfections, similar to Japaneese art.

    #1012736

    To me when listening to others mixes, it is those little imperfections that actually make the mix more interesting. Listening to how beats starts drifting then how quickly the dj notice and put them back in places.
    I always favor those mixes made LIVE with minor mistakes, than those made using programs such as Pro-Tools and took hours of editing. Those pro-tools ones are just too perfect, and eventually made them boring unless they are made very creatively.
    And I notice when mixes are made LIVE, I can feel the energy the dj is trying to deliver.

    #1012746
    gbadegesin
    Participant

    I did not know you could re-edit mixes until quite recently. As such, i have never re-edited any of my mixes and i do not intend to start. Unfortunately for me, i spin genres that tend to have the ‘drift’.My mixing style has had to find a way to adapt to the kind of music i play.
    To answer your question: Yes, i have posted ‘imperfect’ mixes before. I have a place where i use as a testing ground for those kind of mixes. The most amazing thing is that i still get positive feedbacks regardless. It is only human to be imperfect.
    Some songs that had mistakes that were left in have been known to become hits later on

    #1012747
    gbadegesin
    Participant

    I did not know you could re-edit mixes until quite recently. As such, i have never re-edited any of my mixes and i do not intend to start. Unfortunately for me, i spin genres that tend to have the ‘drift’.My mixing style has had to find a way to adapt to the kind of music i play.
    To answer your question: Yes, i have posted ‘imperfect’ mixes before. I have a place where i use as a testing ground for those kind of mixes. The most amazing thing is that i still get positive feedbacks regardless. It is only human to be imperfect.
    Some songs that had mistakes that were left in have been known to become hits later on

    #1012748
    gbadegesin
    Participant

    I did not know you could re-edit mixes until quite recently. As such, i have never re-edited any of my mixes and i do not intend to start. Unfortunately for me, i spin genres that tend to have the ‘drift’.My mixing style has had to find a way to adapt to the kind of music i play.
    To answer your question: Yes, i have posted ‘imperfect’ mixes before. I have a place where i use as a testing ground for those kind of mixes. The most amazing thing is that i still get positive feedbacks regardless. It is only human to be imperfect.
    Some songs that had mistakes that were left in have been known to become hits later on

    #1012776
    J-Zed
    Participant

    I’ve never put out a mix without a mistake, though if there’s a trainwreck part I’ll re-record it from scratch. Sometimes when listening to other mixes, when you hear a mistake you know they’re trying to do something, not just letting tracks play out and syncing everything. It makes it more interesting imo.
    Also, Carl Cox, John Digweed, Adam Beyer… All long time pro djs and every mix I’ve heard by them have a few issues, nobody is perfect!

    #1012786
    DeeJay SiBoogie
    Participant

    Is it live or is it Ableton (who remembers the Memorex ad? lol) I always do live mixes I stream live, record and post them mistakes and all. Listening back makes me aware of things I may not have realised during the mix.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 22 total)
  • The forum ‘The DJ Booth’ is closed to new topics and replies.